Should Your Small Business Go Local or Global?

The other day, a colleague came up to me and said, “Can you take a look at this client’s search marketing campaign?  He wants to target all of North America.”

“What’s his budget?” I asked.

“Five hundred dollars per month.”

This got me thinking about how small businesses perceive the web and the opportunities that it presents to them.

Going Global

Not too long ago, a small business was, by definition, a local business.  Expanding beyond local was expensive.  It required infrastructure, logistics management, more inventory, and more resources.  Small businesses didn’t have any of these things.  Today, for the most part, small businesses still don’t have any of these things.  The difference is that now they don’t need most of them.

The first thing that allowed small businesses to expand beyond the local was the availability of cheap shipping.  This opened up the door to business models that included a centralized location, but that could service a wide area.  Amazon would not be the largest book seller in the world if it weren’t for carriers like UPS, FedEx, DHL and more, competing to bring down the price of bringing goods to the consumer’s front door.

With a distribution network already in place, the ubiquity of the internet made going beyond local a breeze.  With a home on the web, you could just as easily be found by your neighbour, one block over, or by a Texan rancher, or by a Tokyo yuppie.  The dream of going global was no longer reserved for the multinational.

Hugh MacLeod, the copywriter turned artist, turned small business author (affiliate link), often writes about the global microbrand.  The global microbrand is the manifestation of a single individual turning himself into a brand that he can market across the planet.  It appeals, particularly, to creative entrepreneurs like artists and writers, who often have a hard time finding a big enough market for their goods locally.

Hugh has built himself a global microbrand, with little financial investment, and a whole lot of hard work and perseverance.  Still, Hugh has always been quick to point out that while he has become “internet famous,” he has yet to strike it rich.  As sales of his books and his art increase with the size of his audience, it may only be a matter of time, but it hasn’t been easy for him to get there.

Hugh’s story, and stories of those like him, have showcased that it is possible to go global with a small business and be successful. But, I can’t help but feel that going beyond local too quickly makes this process harder than it needs to be.

The Advantages of Local

Before the internet and cheap shipping made it so easy to start a global business, the ordinary route for expanding beyond local went something like this: Start a local business.  Develop a reputation as a trusted member of the local business community.  Grow revenues.  Use revenues from your first location to open a second location.  Wash.  Rinse.  Repeat.

Going global, was a slow and tedious task, especially if every location you opened took as long to grow as your first location.  No wonder people wanted to skip all that and turn to the web.

The thing that we forget is that growing beyond that first location isn’t a direct line of growth, it’s an exponential growth curve.  Sam Walton started off owning a single general store in Arkansas.  Today, Wal-Mart is the biggest retailer in the world, and the Waltons are one of the wealthiest families in the world.  Every single store they opened after the first store got progressively easier to open.  the simple reason for that is that the reptuation from all of the previous stores, made expansion easier.  Today, if you find out a Wal-Mart is opening near you, regardless of your feelings towards the chain, you know exactly what the expect.  Decent, but not excellent, quality goods at everyday low prices.  You just know that.

There are certain advantages to starting locally, and the biggest all have to do with reputation.  When you start your business locally, you know the people around you.  You know your market.  You know your customers.  In fact, when you start locally, you probably knew your customers long before they were your customers.  In many instances, you start off with a built-in group of customers.

Those customers learn your reputation, and they spread it to those closest to them.  They talk about it at the office, at the bar, at Sunday barbecues.  Word of mouth is really easy to achieve locally.  Getting brand awareness locally is also really easy.  How easy?  Start wearing a T-shirt with your business’ name on it, and walk around your city.  If you don’t think that’ll generate leads, then there’s an issue with your business, not with your city.

Aside from that, in the local space, we all already have pre-established networks that we can use to spread the word of our business, all of which contributes to its success.

So, that’s great for getting that first location up and running, but how does that help in going beyond local?  Quite simply because now you have a history when you open your second location.  You have experience, you have testimonials, and you can point to all of these as social proof that what you do works.  This makes the second location that much more likely to succeed.

The Problem with Skipping the Local Step

The big problem with skipping the initial local step, and going global first, is that you’re removing all of your pre-existing advantages.  The web, and the world are huge, scary places, and most of us don’t have many connections “out there.”  If you’re concentrating on making worldwide sales, your backyard barbecue probably isn’t going to do you a whole world of good as a networking event.

I concede that there’s no reason why the people who would have bought from you if you were local won’t buy from you if you’re trying to go global, but the fact of the matter is, companies trying to go global have a different mindset.  They start thinking of their market in terms of generalities, and oftentimes, this isn’t the best way to attract local buyers.

The other big issue with skippling the local step is that while many of the problems of going global have been resolved by modern conveniences, some still remain.  True, you only need a single warehouse, and can ship around the world relatively cheaply.  Alternatively, you can use drop shipping services.  You don’t need physical locations all around the world, you can take orders from a single website.

But what about our client from the beginning of this article?  Is he ready to go global?

You’ll notice that the first question I asked my colleague wasn’t, “What does the client do?” or “Where is he located?”  Instead, I asked, “What’s his budget?”

The internet has done some incredible things for marketing.  It has lowered the cost of marketing to the point where a small business can realistically compete with a multinational.  However, it has not caused miracles to happen.  A $500 budget for search engine marketing campaign is still a small budget, and while you can and should see good results for that budget on a local scale, it simply doesn’t make sense on a continental scale.  It’s the classic definition of spreading yourself too thin.  Yes, search engine marketing is a pay for performance medium.  Yes, you only pay when your ads are clicked.  Yes, mathematically speaking if you convert 10% of all visits on your site, it shouldn’t matter where those visits are coming from.

But it does matter.

Your clicks will be spread across an entire continent.  You’ll get single visits from various places. And, while mathematically, a 10% conversation rate, should mean that 10 out of every 100 visitors will convert, in practice, when all 100 of your customers are sitting in different locations, it rarely ever works that way.

Furthermore, none of what you learn from your campaign has any meaning because your data isn’t significant.  In order for data to be significant, you need to have a certain quantity of data.  Not only that, but all of the data points in that data set need to be similar.  When you’re targeting a wide area with a small budget, all of your data points are different.  You never get significant data, so it’s impossible to optimize your marketing.

The bottom line is that in many media, it still takes bigger budgets to broadcast on a wider scale.

Start local, hit your stride, then bust out of your local market.  Not only will it be easier to do, but you’ll be better prepared to take on the hyper-competitive global market.

What’s been your experience in the local vs. global game?  Have you gone beyond local?  Have you purposely chosen to stay local.  Share your story in the comments.